Rameshwar's IAS

Criticism of Human Development Index (HDI)

Tags: Gig Economy Economy WTO WTO Public Stockholding MSP Economic Growth Masala Bond Environmental Performance Index Forecast of Economic Growth Functions of the Finance Commission

A healthy and long life coupled with knowledge and a good living standard form the imperative facets of human development and the HDI or, the Human Development Index measures these in summary. The normalised indices for each of the three dimensions' geometric means make up the HDI. The life expectancy at birth is used to evaluate the health dimension, while the mean number of years spent in school for persons 25 years and older and the anticipated number of years spent in school for young children are used to evaluate the education dimension. Gross national income per person is used to quantify the standard of living dimension. The HDI employs the logarithm of income to illustrate how income becomes less significant as GNI rises. The three HDI dimension indices' results are then combined using geometric mean to generate a composite index.

The HDI is used to divert attention away from the conventional economic statistics and onto human consequences among decision-makers, the media, and humanitarian organisations. It was developed to once again underline that, rather than economic growth, the most important factor in determining a nation's level of development should be its people and their capacities. The Non-Scheduled banks HDI is also used to examine national policy decisions and understand how two nations with comparable income per person can achieve vastly different levels of human development. For instance, two nations might have comparable revenues per person but vastly different life expectancies and literacy rates, resulting in one nation having a significantly higher HDI than the other. These differences encourage discussion of health and education-related government policies to ascertain why what is possible in one country is out of reach in the other. The HDI is additionally used to draw attention to variations between nations, provinces, or states, as well as among genders, ethnicities, and other socioeconomic groups. In many nations, bringing attention to internal discrepancies along these lines has sparked national discourse.

Criticism of the HDI or, the Human Development Index - Environmental concerns, ecosystem inequality, poverty, and gender imbalance are not taken into account by the HDI. The HDI can be used to analyse the effectiveness of national policies by comparing the levels of human development in two nations with comparable GNI per capita. These disparities might spark discussion on the top goals for governmental policy. Human development is oversimplified by the HDI, and only a portion of it is actually captured. Inequalities, poverty, human security, empowerment, etc. are not addressed. As a larger proxy for some of the important challenges of human development, inequality, gender imbalance, and poverty, the HDRO offers several composite indices. Analyzing other markers and data from the HDR statistics annex is necessary to get a more complete picture of a nation's human development status.

Questions ? Contact Us